damnlines for iPhoneLive lines & push alerts — freeGet
damnlinesdamnlines.com
Watchlist // Nolita
pizza · Nolita, ManhattanNO. 38 / 1960

Prince Street Pizza

A Nolita takeout window whose Spicy Spring — cupped-pepperoni Sicilian squares — turned a slice counter into a TikTok pilgrimage.

27 Prince St, New York, NY 10012

// Live lines nearby

No camera at Prince Street Pizza yet — these are the closest live lines we cover.

//Put a camera here

damnlines hasn't pointed a lens at Prince Street Pizza yet. The most-wanted lines get a camera first.

0
votes
#12 most-wanted in Nolita
//The line

Prince Street Pizza is a takeout slice counter at 27 Prince St in Nolita. No seating; you order at the window. The line is almost entirely for one item: the Spicy Spring, a square Sicilian slice piled with cupped pepperoni. Time Out lists it as Fra Diavolo sauce, spicy sopressata, and fresh mozzarella. NYC Tourism calls the shop a 'workaday slice shop' surrounded by tony boutiques.

The crowd is a recent phenomenon. A regular in a Yelp Q&A thread remembers 'waiting three-ish minutes for my slice' before the shop blew up, and now describes 'a line out the door from what seems like open to close.' The Spicy Spring is a recurring TikTok subject, which is what converted a neighborhood slice window into a tourist stop. Because it is counter service, the queue is on the sidewalk and moves at slice-counter speed, not sit-down speed.

On wait length, reports vary and none of it is live. A Tripadvisor reviewer said they 'waited about 20 min to order' and added that 'lines can be longer.' The standard advice from Yelp regulars is to skip lunch and go earlier or later; visitor guides describe weekday afternoons as the calmest window and weekends as the busiest. We do not have a camera at Prince Street Pizza, so check our nearby Nolita and SoHo cameras for a real-time read on the neighborhood.

//When the line peaks
Daily lunch hours: regulars call this the worst time and advise going earlier or later (Yelp Q&A thread) Busy days: a regular describes a line 'from open to close' (Yelp Q&A thread) Weekends busier than weekdays, with weekday afternoons reported as the quietest window (visitor guides) Late night: Time Out lists it as a late-night spot; kitchen runs to 2am Thu-Sat and midnight Sun-Wed

Patterns as reported by press and regulars — not measured by damnlines.

//Getting in

Reservations: No reservations - Prince Street Pizza is a counter-service slice shop, per The Infatuation's review, which categorizes it under "Cheap Eats" rather than a reservation-based sit-down restaurant.

Walk-ins: As a slice-shop format covered under The Infatuation's "Cheap Eats" and "Late Nights" categories, service is walk-up/counter-order, though the review does not detail line lengths or peak-time waits.

//FAQ

How long is the wait at Prince Street Pizza?

A Tripadvisor reviewer reported waiting about 20 minutes to order and noted that lines can be longer. A Yelp regular describes a line 'from open to close' on busy days. It is a counter with no seating, so the queue is on the sidewalk and moves at slice-counter speed. (No live damnlines camera here yet — this is reported guidance, not a live count.)

What is the best time to go to Prince Street Pizza?

Regulars in a Yelp Q&A thread advise avoiding lunch hours and going earlier or later. Visitor guides report weekday afternoons as the quietest window and weekends as the busiest.

Does Prince Street Pizza take reservations or have seating?

No. It is a takeout slice counter at 27 Prince St. You order at the window and eat standing or walking, which is why the crowd shows up as a sidewalk line rather than a dining-room wait.

What is the line actually for at Prince Street Pizza?

Mostly the Spicy Spring, a square Sicilian slice piled with cupped pepperoni. Time Out lists it as Fra Diavolo sauce, spicy sopressata, and fresh mozzarella. It is a recurring TikTok subject, which is what turned a neighborhood slice window into a tourist stop.

What are Prince Street Pizza's hours?

Time Out lists Mon-Wed 11:30am-midnight, Thu-Sat 11:30am-2am, and Sun 11:30am-midnight. Confirm before a late-night trip.

Does Prince Street Pizza take reservations?

No - per The Infatuation's review, it's a counter-service slice shop (listed under "Cheap Eats"), not a reservation-based restaurant.

Can you walk into Prince Street Pizza?

Yes, service is walk-up counter ordering per its slice-shop format described by The Infatuation, though the review doesn't specify typical wait or line details.

Sources: Time Out New York: Prince Street Pizza · Yelp Q&A: Prince Street Pizza (line 'open to close', avoid lunch) · Tripadvisor review: 'waited about 20 min to order' · NYC Tourism: Prince Street Pizza (Nolita) · The Infatuation - Prince Street Pizza review

Prince Street Pizza — The Line & How to Get In · Nolita, NYC | damnlines